Gun Law Reform and Mental Health: the Myth of the “Lone, Deranged Criminal”

Pictured: man in a protest holding up a sign that says: You don't spread democracy with a barrel of a gun- Helen Thomas

Just a few months shy of the 10th anniversary of the deadliest mass school shooting at Sandyhook Elementary in Newtown, Connecticut, Robb Elementary School in Uvalde, Texas, is now the deadliest since then.


The NRA issued a statement using the oft-repeated “act of a lone, deranged criminal” phrase that Republicans and the gun lobby alike have repeatedly used to distance themselves from accountability to describe Salvador Ramos’ deadly actions and the actions of other mass shooters.

According to the Pew Research Center, gun ownership is primarily tied to protection as the motive for ownership with two-thirds of gun owners citing protection as the primary reason they own a gun. White men are the largest gun ownership, group.

Yet with the continued proliferation of guns, regulation of gun ownership hasn’t kept up.

The powerful lobbying group National Rifle Association made political contributions to 50 senators in their respective states, with the largest amounts going to prominent Republican senators such as Utah’s Mitt Romney and Florida’s Marco Rubio. Both senators have avidly taken anti-gun control positions while accepting millions of dollars in campaign donations. The trend continues with other Republican elected officials who have accepted NRA donations also taking anti-gun reform positions.

Mental Ilness Found Amongst Mass Murder Shooters

Gun lobbyists such as the NRA control a massive amount of political influence despite statistics getting worse for gun violence in the U.S. At the same time, research indicates that mental health illness was found amongst the majority of mass shooters who survived their deadly rampages. Researchers were able to study 35 shooters and found that 28 had a history of mental illness that wasn’t being treated at the time of the shooting.

With the NRA attempting to push the “lone deranged shooter” narrative, the converse of that would be improved mental health screening, treatment, and mental health checks before purchasing a weapon. In Texas, where Robb Elementary School is located, Governor Greg Abbot also blamed the shooting on “mental health” issues despite there being no evidence of that in this instance, and despite having just cut mental health funding by over 200 milion dollars.

Weapons manufacturers continue to benefit from the lack of regulation which makes it easier to continue selling guns. In many states, everyday things like purchasing allergy medicine, owning a car, or getting an abortion are significantly harder than buying a gun and thousands of rounds of ammo. But because it’s easy to scapegoat mental illness for every single mass shooting, actual solutions from funding mental health treatment to putting common-sense regulations in place for gun ownership remain elusive.

Limiting access to guns is just one of the many things public policymakers must do to reduce the gun violence epidemic gripping the nation. It’s clear that with mental illness playing a role in many mass shootings, funding the services needed for those who are at risk of acting on violent thoughts is another common-sense approach that’s needed.

A Nation and Community Mourns

Mass shootings having an adverse effect on the mental health for the victims’ families but also on the public at large. A growing number of people are citing mass shootings as a genuine societal fear. According to the Brady Report, “up to 95 percent of people exposed to mass shootings experience symptoms of PTSD in the early days after the incident, and most of those individuals feel the psychological effects of the trauma months later.”

An interdisciplinary approach is needed to solve this problem: common-sense regulation of gun buying and ownership, holding our elected officials responsible for inaction, and providing access to mental health resources for everyone. Until then data convincingly tells us that we’re not waiting for the possibility of another mass shooting, we’re waiting for the inevitble next one.

If you are in need of mental health support, visit the Luz mental health and trauma support page for easy to reach resources.


Graphic design featuring a smiling woman surrounded by moving boxes

Created in partnership with MakeMyMove

The beginning of the COVID-19 pandemic marked a pivotal moment for the entire world. It’s crucial to acknowledge the severe hardship and grief that the pandemic caused. It’s also important to recognize how it forced the world to adapt and reimagine how work could be done.

Keep ReadingShow less
photo from a screengrab from the documentary film Paris is Burning showing Angie Xtravaganza

Angie Xtravaganza, an iconic figure in the LGBTQ+ community, was a strong voice for transgender rights, a significant promoter of the queer ballroom culture, and a prominent representation of Latinx individuals within the queer community. Her life story, though marked by personal challenges, continues to inspire countless individuals worldwide, transcending generations and communities alike.

Keep ReadingShow less
Image of an Afro-Latina woman holding a sign, referring to Junetheen, that says: "For my history. For my ancestors. For my community. For a better future."

In 2021 it became official: Juneteenth became a federal holiday meant to commemorate the emancipation of enslaved Africans after the American Civil War. The fact that it took as much time as it did to officially acknowledge the momentous occasion shows just how big a deal making Juneteenth a federal holiday actually is.

Keep ReadingShow less